| 2014 |
Michael Schroeder |
Independent Team |
| 2013 |
Matt Frahm |
Independent Team |
|
Mike Bolling |
Independent Team |
| 2012 |
Andrew Brauer |
Independent Team |
| 2011 |
Joey Gradney |
Independent Team |
| 2010 |
Joe Scumaci |
Independent Team |
| 2008 |
Billy Duffy |
Independent Team |
| 2005 |
Ahren Baranski |
Independent Team |
| 2004 |
Matt Petrusek |
Independent Team |
| 2002 |
Eddie Fink |
Independent Team |
|
Keith Nawrocki |
Independent Team |
| 2001 |
Jeff Johnson |
Independent Team |
|
Mike Landry |
Independent Team |
| 2000 |
J.J. Furmaniak |
San Diego Padres (22nd Round) |
| 1997 |
Joe Spano |
Independent Team |
|
Mike Steele |
Independent Team |
| 1996 |
Rick Moss |
Minnesota Twins (44th Round) |
|
Josh Barron |
Independent Team |
|
Brian Gibbons |
Independent Team |
|
Derek Hart |
Independent Team |
|
Mike Morici |
Independent Team |
|
Scott Shuster |
Independent Team |
|
Bryan Thornton |
Independent Team |
|
Kurt Bruksch |
Independent Team |
| 1995 |
Mike Vavrek |
Colorado Rockies (5th Round) |
| 1994 |
John Nape |
Singed to Minor League Co-op Contract |
|
Rob Ryan |
Independent Team |
|
Chris Priest |
Independent Team |
| 1992 |
Tim Unroe |
Milwaukee Brewers (28th Round) |
| 1991 |
Andy Stemler |
Cleveland Indians (61st Round) |
|
Mike Stevenson |
Chicago White Sox |
|
Jim Guidi |
Independent Team |
| 1990 |
Rick Huisman |
San Francisco Giants (3rd Round) |
|
Ernie Young |
Oakland Athletics (10th Round) |
| 1989 |
Tim Pinkowski |
California Angels (32nd Round) |
| 1988 |
Steve Kirwin |
California Angels (36th Round) |
| 1987 |
Pat Disabato |
New York Mets (23rd round) |
|
Larry Scannell |
Boston Red Sox (16th Round) |
|
John Sabatino |
Chicago White Sox (16th Round) |
|
Dan Harlan |
Kansas City Royals |
|
Mark Granato |
Toronto Blue Jays |
| 1986 |
Bill Kazmierczak |
Chicago Cubs (6th Round) |
| 1982 |
Kirk Vucsko |
Los Angeles Dodgers (28th Round) |
| 1981 |
Bob Tumpane |
Atlanta Braves (20th round) |
| 1980 |
Jim Walsh |
Chicago Cubs (5th Round) |
|
Ken Weislak |
Montreal Expos (7th Round) |
| 1979 |
Joe Lorenz |
San Francisco Giants (30th Round) |
| 1978 |
Rick Ramos |
Montreal Expos (17th Round) |
|
Joe Piechota |
Montreal Expos |
|
Jim Payne |
Chicago Cubs |
| 1976 |
George DiMatteo |
Chicago Cubs |
|
Ken Jones |
Chicago White Sox |
|
Paul Stevens |
Kansas City Rolays (16th Round) |
| 1975 |
Jerry Quigley |
California Angels (18th Round) |
|
Ray Crowley |
Montreal Expos (25th round) |
|
Jim Alessio |
Chicago Cubs |
| 1974 |
Tom Brennan |
Cleveland Indians (1st Round) |
|
Mike Manderino |
Chicago Cubs |
|
Steve Verban |
Chicago Cubs |
| 1973 |
Wally Onysio |
Chicago Cubs |
|
Gary Beese |
California Angels (6th Round) |
| 1972 |
Rick Beeler |
Chicago Cubs |
|
Joe Pomykala |
Chicago White Sox (14th Round) |
|
Bill Scholl |
New York Mets |
|
Alan Wasik |
Chicago White Sox (22nd Round)- Drafted but did not sign |
| 1971 |
Emil Verban |
Philadelphia Phillies |
| 1969 |
Jim Brunette |
Chicago Cubs (7th round) |
|
Art Pauls |
Los Angeles Dodgers (14th Round) |
|
Art Janeke |
Los Angeles Dodgers |
|
Roger Gifford |
Washington Senators (36th Round) |
| 1967 |
Mike Ford |
Minnesota Twins (41st Round) |
|
Gerg Washburn |
California Angels (1st Round) |
| 1966 |
Bob Miller |
Washington Senators (9th Round) |
| 1965 |
Terry Milani |
St. Louis Cardinals (2nd Round) |
| 1963 |
Ed Spiezio |
St. Louis Cardinals |
| 1956 |
Bill Palka |
Cleveland Indians |
