| Jake Lotz, P |
NCBWA Midwest Honorable Mention, 2022 |
| Jake Karaba, P |
ABCA Midwest First Team, 2021 |
| D2CCA Midwest Second Team, 2021 |
| NCBWA Midwest Second Team, 2021 |
| Michael O'Brien, SS |
ABCA Midwest First Team, 2021 |
| D2CCA Midwest First Team, 2021 |
| NCBWA Midwest First Team, 2021 |
| Anthony Rios, C |
D2CCA Midwest Second Team, 2021 |
| Brandon Post, OF |
ABCA Midwest Second Team, 2019 |
| NCBWA Midwest Second Team, 2019 |
| D2CCA Midwest Second Team, 2019 |
| Brandon Collins, OF |
ABCA Midwest Second Team, 2017 |
| Ben Albano, OF |
ABCA Midwest Second Team, 2012, '14 |
|
Daktronics All-Midwest Second Team, 2012 |
| Michael Schroeder, 1B/P |
ABCA Midwest First Team, 2013 |
|
Daktronics All-Midwest Second Team, 2013 |
| Tom Helwich, P |
ABCA Midwest First Team, 2013 |
|
Daktronics All-Midwest First Team, 2013 |
| Jake Murray, OF |
ABCA Midwest Second Team, 2013 |
| Matt Frahm, P |
Daktronics All-Midwest Second Team, 2013 |
| Mike Bolling, OF |
Daktronics All-Midwest Second Team, 2012 |
| Joe Scumaci, P |
Dakronics All-Midwest First Team, 2010 |
|
ABCA Midwest Second Team, 2010 |
|
NCBWA Midwest Second Team, 2010 |
| Andy Sweet, 2B |
ABCA Central Second Team, 2004 |
| J.J. Furmaniak, SS |
ABCA North Central First Team, 2000 |
